Best Crib Mattresses of 2018: Your Ultimate Buying Guide

As a general rule, you should never leave your baby alone. There is only one exception in this case – you don’t have to necessarily watch over your precious one while they’re sleeping. In order for your baby to get a good quality sleep, you need the right crib mattress.

There are many mattresses to choose from, and it’s not easy to get the right one. However, with this guide, your life will get a bit easier.

We’ve managed to compile a very detailed overview of all the best crib mattresses at this point in time. By the end of the article, you will also know everything about crib mattresses in general, and you will be able to rightfully call yourself an expert.

Let’s get started!

Before we begin…

We’d like to point out that each crib mattress that you will find here is the best choice in its own respective category. No matter which of these mattresses you end up buying, you will certainly get a long-lasting solution that will please both you and your baby. All of them were highly praised by many parents around the world and, equally, they all became well-known trademarks of superb quality. So, you can’t really make a mistake.

Sealy Soybean Foam Mattress – our choice for the best natural foam mattress

The first crib mattress on our list is beyond amazing. Sealy is a true brand in and they just don’t know how to make a faulty mattress. This one is no exception.

The first thing we’d like to point out is that the mattress is entirely waterproof (which is great). You may feel as if the surface was made of pure plastic but, in reality, the waterproof cover prevents any leaks from getting inside at night. Unlike many other mattresses, this one has special material pockets that allow for much better ventilation.

These pockets have another function – they prevent the awful smell that becomes more apparent as the mattress gets older. The mattress itself is very supportive and you can carry it around effortlessly as you go.  Also, you can change the crib sheets very easily. However, you might notice slightly rounded corners if you use crib sheets that are too tight. But, that shouldn’t worry you, as its basic functionality will remain intact.

If you buy this mattress, you will even get a lifetime warranty on both materials and workmanship. So, if you were not sure whether this mattress is a good choice for you, this should hopefully be a solid reassurance.

Colgate Eco Classica – our choice for the best dual firm mattress

If there is one way we could describe this mattress it would be “a crib mattress with intelligent design”. It is a perfect choice if your baby is now transitioning into the toddler phase. One side is very soft whereas the other is firm enough for an average infant. As both sides have their own marks, you shouldn’t have issues to choose the right one.

Another thing we have to add is that this mattress has no off-gassing issues whatsoever. It’s actually quite the contrary – the mattress comes with a special Greenguard certification. What does that mean? It means that it meets all the necessary standards for air quality. The mattress doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals or any other dangerous substances that could harm your baby. As a result, both you and your precious one can sleep tight and easy!

The mattress has a backing that is entirely waterproof and a cover made of organic cotton. Even though you could see a wet cover, no water will get into the mattress itself. We should also add that you can easily fit this mattress into a basic crib.

However, some parents report that you may have a certain problem with this mattress. Namely, it might feel too tight if you’re using crib sheets. Overall, it’s not a huge issue, but we had to point it out nonetheless.

Colgate Eco Classica is, undoubtedly, one of the best dual firm crib mattresses that you can buy today. It’s natural, lightweight and very affordable. We can certainly recommend it to every parent.

Kittrich Bedding Memory Foam Mattress – our choice for the best memory foam mattress

As a concept, memory foam is becoming more and more popular nowadays, so we shouldn’t be surprised to see so many memory foam crib mattresses on the market. This memory foam crib mattress, in particular, is also one of the best mattresses that you can get at the moment.

Just like the previously mentioned mattresses, this one is also entirely waterproof, so you can rest assured that no liquid will end up inside the mattresses. Other than that, the mattress has a special cover that you can easily remove by washing it in your washing machine.

Although this product is primarily made from synthetic foam, you shouldn’t be concerned. It meets all the necessary safety standards. Moreover, the mattress is entirely dust-resistant and hypoallergenic, which means that it’s 100% safe from a medical standpoint.

This mattress offers a 10-year warranty, so we believe that it’s made to last quite a while.

Naturepedic Organic Mattress – our choice for the best organic crib mattress

If you really want an organic mattress, you should look no further – Naturepedic Organic Mattress is pretty much your best bet. Even though this mattress is quite expensive, it’s well worth every penny.

Both sides of the mattress use organic materials exclusively, and there are no dangerous chemicals whatsoever. Furthermore, the mattress is 100% dual firm, so both babies and toddlers can use it just as effectively.

Another great thing about this mattress is that you can clean it very easily. It takes no effort to wipe it down as the surface doesn’t absorb any liquids and it’s highly flexible. Thanks to a full polyethylene surface, the mattress also comes with exceptional durability. So, if you’re looking for a long-term investment, Naturapedic Organic Mattress should be one of your primary choices.

If that wasn’t enough, we can also add that the Naturapedic customer service is beyond amazing. They are always ready to help you out, and you can reach them anytime you want.

It’s true that the Naturepedic Organic Mattress is very pricey but, if money is not your concern, you should definitely consider this option.

Safety 1st White Crib Mattress – our choice for the best cost-effective crib mattress

Whereas the previous mattress is a great choice for all people who are willing to spend a lot of money to get their dreamlike product, this one is quite the opposite. If you’re looking for the best cost-effective mattress, look no further!

Even though this is a foam mattress, its edges are well formed and quite durable. The foam has very high density, and it provides a very solid sleeping surface that your precious one will surely appreciate. The mattress is also very lightweight which means that you can easily carry it around as you like.

The cover is also outstanding – it’s resistant to smells, stains, and even tears. And the cleaning process? Easy as can be (just like in all previous cases)! You can even take off the vinyl cover if you want to change it (or wash it, for that matter).

If you want a great mix of price and value, you can’t go wrong with Safety 1st White Crib Mattress.

Frequently asked questions

1.   How can we define the term “crib mattress”?

So, what is really a crib mattress? It’s basically a tiny mattress that you can combine with your crib. Each and every baby crib provides a safe (and solid) sleeping surface that your tiny one can sleep on.

2. When should I buy a mattress?

Ideally, you should buy your crib mattress whenever you decide to get a crib in the first place. A mattress is always a good investment as you can use it even when your baby becomes a toddler.

3. How long can I use my baby crib mattress?

There is no actual time limit in this case. While some parents abandon their baby cribs by the time their child grows into a toddler, others keep using it even after that period ends.

4. When should I replace my mattress?

In general, a typical mattress should serve you well for about three years on average. If you maintain it properly, it can last even longer. But, as soon as you see that your mattress is wearing out, it’s time to choose another one.

5. How many types of crib mattresses can I find?

There are several different types of crib mattresses, and we basically mentioned all of them above – foam, coil spring, pocket spring, memory foam, and natural (organic) mattress. They all have their pros and cons and, in the end, you should choose the type that suits your baby’s needs the most.

Leave a Comment